Starboard guns ready to fire, Cap'n

Vox tells his critics to put up or shut up in spectacular fashion:
Back when I first responded to NK Jemisin's various attacks and lies in my inimitably calm and factual manner, the SFWA writers reacted with much the same combination of outrage and vitriol with which the Pink SF/Fers have met the news of the nomination of one of my works for the Hugo Award. However, when I invited them to attempt to prove that anything I said was a) false, or, b) racist, every single one of them tucked tail and ran away. Every single one of them. 
Patrick Nielsen Hayden was nothing but talk. John Scalzi was nothing but talk. Stephen Gould was nothing but talk. Jason Sanford was nothing but talk. Teresa Nielsen Hayden was nothing but talk. Charles Stross was nothing but talk. Every single one of these self-proclaimed champions of the marginalized and the oppressed fell silent rather than defend their supposed principles.

This may be because they were afraid that I could make my case, or perhaps they simply feared to have their own secret racism exposed to their peers. It's even possible they were sufficiently self-aware to realize how silly they would look if they attempted to define racism down to "being insufficiently obsequious to an individual of predominantly sub-Saharan descent." 
So, perhaps the larger community of fen is capable of doing what the SFWA community was not, which is actually proving the truth of their oft-repeated charges. I'm therefore extending an invitation to publicly make the case for my supposed racism to anyone who has asserted that I am a racist on the basis of my statements concerning "the educated, but ignorant half-savage" NK Jemisin. 
If you truly believe what you are asserting about me, then I invite you to demonstrate the truth of your beliefs here. It should be easy, after all, right? If my statements are so blatantly racist as you claim them to be, how could you not show it to all and sundry. I will not only post your argument here in its entirety, but am willing to honestly answer any questions you might have, without evasion, with the sole requirement that you must agree to honestly answer my questions, without evasion, until we mutually agree that no further discussion is possible. 
And if no one steps forward, well, everyone will then know that these accusations of racism are spurious, those making them don't truly believe what they are saying, and none of the accusers have the courage of their supposedly anti-racist convictions. The black community will know that for all their talk of inclusiveness and equality, not a single white individual in SF/F was willing to stand up and defend them. And let's face it, if every single anti-racist in the community is afraid to publicly confront racists, then it should be readily apparent that the racists are going to win in the end.
Vox being who he is, I have a strong suspicion that we're going to be in for considerable amusement over the next few weeks. The man has a positive gift for making his opponents look like complete idiots. The fact that he does it through nothing more dangerous than rigourously reasoned, logical, and factual prose makes it even more impressive.

Now, as to whether Vox actually is racist or not- I don't know and quite frankly I don't care. My bar for what I consider to be genuinely racist is extremely high. All I can say is that, in over five years of reading what Vox has to write, not once have I ever been angered or offended by any of his content that deals, even in the most tangential form, with race. (Then again, I happen to have immense respect for Vox Day and his critical faculties, so it's likely that I'm biased here.)

Half the problem here is proving what is and is not "racist". If "racism" just means "I'm not a white person and you hurt my feelings!", then that's an abysmally stupid metric and says much more about the idiot who lets himself (or herself, more likely) get butthurt than it does about the man writing the content that caused the offence. If it means "you threatened aggression, whether physical or otherwise, against me specifically because of my skin colour or race!", then I suspect it's going to be a cold day in Hell before anyone proves that Vox did or said anything of the sort.

The onus is now on his critics to prove their allegations. If they do, then I expect that Vox will acknowledge their points, apologise where necessary, and then we can all get on with life. If they do NOT (which is a vastly more likely outcome), then the moral and intellectual cowardice of the liblepr rabbits of this world will have been laid bare for all to see.

Get some beer and popcorn, friends. This is going to be fun.


Popular Posts